Why brands failed to amuse this April Fool’s Day

April Fool's Day 2025 BrewDog's Hot Beer
BrandsFeaturesOpinion

In a world where brands are increasingly sanitised and risk-averse, April 1st is an opportunity to be irreverent, engaging, and culturally switched-on.

But too often, these efforts feel like brands flexing a muscle they haven’t trained, writes Jon Tipple, chief strategy officer at FutureBrand.

Jon Tipple, chief strategy officer at FutureBrand.
Jon Tipple, chief strategy officer at FutureBrand.

Yesterday (1 April) we saw Branston Beans Lip Gloss, BrewDog’s Hot Beer, Terry’s Chocolate Mint Toothpaste and, perhaps most bizarrely, Babybel’s Wax Sleeping Bag.

But be honest, did any of them actually make you laugh out loud at your desk?

No? Me neither.

This isn’t just a one-day issue.

The average brand Personality score in the FutureBrand Index has dropped from 36% in 2022 to 33% in 2024, showing how hard it is for brands to maintain a distinctive, engaging voice.


Subscribe to Marketing Beat for free

Sign up here to get the latest agency-related news sent straight to your inbox each morning


April Fool's Day 2025 Branston Beans Lip Gloss
Branston Beans Lip Gloss ad

It’s a symptom of a broader problem – too many brands are stuck in a generic tone of voice for fear of saying the wrong thing.

The recipe for a great April Fool’s [prank] is twofold:

First, you need a well-established, recognisable brand to subvert consumers’ expectations.

Second, you need to be genuinely funny. Done well, engaging with April Fool’s can signal agility, confidence, and a clear understanding of your brand’s voice.

Burger King's April Fool's pranks in 1998.
Burger King’s April Fool’s pranks in 1998.

Just look at Burger King’s legendary Left-Handed Whopper in 1998, a full-scale ad campaign that felt bold, unexpected, and entirely on-brand for a company with anti-establishment flair baked into its DNA.

Ultimately, brands should have an April Fool’s mindset 364 days a year. Creativity, boldness, and the willingness to surprise your audience shouldn’t be reserved for just one morning in April.

And with a little more practice, maybe next year’s jokes will actually make us laugh.

BrandsFeaturesOpinion
BrandsFeaturesOpinion

Share:

Why brands failed to amuse this April Fool’s Day

April Fool's Day 2025 BrewDog's Hot Beer

Social

SUBSCRIBE TO OUR DAILY NEWSLETTER

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Most Read

In a world where brands are increasingly sanitised and risk-averse, April 1st is an opportunity to be irreverent, engaging, and culturally switched-on.

But too often, these efforts feel like brands flexing a muscle they haven’t trained, writes Jon Tipple, chief strategy officer at FutureBrand.

Jon Tipple, chief strategy officer at FutureBrand.
Jon Tipple, chief strategy officer at FutureBrand.

Yesterday (1 April) we saw Branston Beans Lip Gloss, BrewDog’s Hot Beer, Terry’s Chocolate Mint Toothpaste and, perhaps most bizarrely, Babybel’s Wax Sleeping Bag.

But be honest, did any of them actually make you laugh out loud at your desk?

No? Me neither.

This isn’t just a one-day issue.

The average brand Personality score in the FutureBrand Index has dropped from 36% in 2022 to 33% in 2024, showing how hard it is for brands to maintain a distinctive, engaging voice.


Subscribe to Marketing Beat for free

Sign up here to get the latest agency-related news sent straight to your inbox each morning


April Fool's Day 2025 Branston Beans Lip Gloss
Branston Beans Lip Gloss ad

It’s a symptom of a broader problem – too many brands are stuck in a generic tone of voice for fear of saying the wrong thing.

The recipe for a great April Fool’s [prank] is twofold:

First, you need a well-established, recognisable brand to subvert consumers’ expectations.

Second, you need to be genuinely funny. Done well, engaging with April Fool’s can signal agility, confidence, and a clear understanding of your brand’s voice.

Burger King's April Fool's pranks in 1998.
Burger King’s April Fool’s pranks in 1998.

Just look at Burger King’s legendary Left-Handed Whopper in 1998, a full-scale ad campaign that felt bold, unexpected, and entirely on-brand for a company with anti-establishment flair baked into its DNA.

Ultimately, brands should have an April Fool’s mindset 364 days a year. Creativity, boldness, and the willingness to surprise your audience shouldn’t be reserved for just one morning in April.

And with a little more practice, maybe next year’s jokes will actually make us laugh.

BrandsFeaturesOpinion

RELATED STORIES

Most Read

Latest Feature

Latest Podcast

Menu

Marketing Beat has stopped reporting.

For retail Marketing insight please visit RG.

Retail Gazette